aftershock 0 Posted May 11, 2011 Share Posted May 11, 2011 I would score them: McGregor 9 Alexander 5 Whittaker 6 Bougherra 6 Weir 7 Papac 6 Foster 5 Bartley 6 Davis 7 Edu 4 Ness 6 McCulloch 6 Hutton 6 Weiss 7 Wylde 6 Diouf 5 Naismith 8 Lafferty 7 Jelavic 9 Miller 9 Healy 3 Beattie 1 0 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
calscot 0 Posted May 11, 2011 Share Posted May 11, 2011 I would score them: McGregor 9 Alexander 5 Whittaker 6 Bougherra 6 Weir 7 Papac 6 Foster 5 Bartley 6 Davis 7 Edu 4 Ness 6 McCulloch 6 Hutton 6 Weiss 7 Wylde 6 Diouf 5 Naismith 8 Lafferty 7 Jelavic 9 Miller 9 Healy 3 Beattie 1 I'm more in agreement with than than the OP. 0 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Zappa 0 Posted May 11, 2011 Share Posted May 11, 2011 I would score them: McGregor 9 Whittaker 7 Bougherra 7 Weir 8 Papac 7 Foster 6 Bartley 7 Davis 8 Edu 5 Ness 6 McCulloch 6 Weiss 8 Wylde 6 Diouf 6 Naismith 8 Lafferty 7 Jelavic 9 Miller 9 I've left out Healy, Beattie, Alexander and Hutton since they really haven't featured much. Could have left out Ness and Foster as well, but they both did great when called upon, so deserve a mention. I realize that he's improved lately, but my lowest score for the season overall goes to Edu, who wouldn't even get a pass mark of 5 if he hadn't shown the improvement we've seen in a handful of games. 0 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
bluebear54 0 Posted May 11, 2011 Share Posted May 11, 2011 I would score them: McGregor 9 Whittaker 7 Bougherra 7 Weir 8 Papac 7 Foster 6 Bartley 7 Davis 8 Edu 5 Ness 6 McCulloch 6 Weiss 8 Wylde 6 Diouf 6 Naismith 8 Lafferty 7 Jelavic 9 Miller 9 I've left out Healy, Beattie, Alexander and Hutton since they really haven't featured much. Could have left out Ness and Foster as well, but they both did great when called upon, so deserve a mention. I realize that he's improved lately, but my lowest score for the season overall goes to Edu, who wouldn't even get a pass mark of 5 if he hadn't shown the improvement we've seen in a handful of games. Would agree with most there. Boogie should really have a "Must do better - not trying" Likewise Diouf. Edu should have "Has improved recently and is now showing his ability." Likewise Lafferty. Weiss? Well, he's an enigma. He's really capable of doing more I think, because we've only seen the real Weiss in sporadic flashes. So, 5 for Weiss, 4 for Diouf and Boogie, and over the season 4 for Edu and Lafferty. I know, I'm a hard taskmaster! 0 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
pete 2,499 Posted May 11, 2011 Share Posted May 11, 2011 I would score them: McGregor 9 Alexander 5 Whittaker 6 Bougherra 6 Weir 7 Papac 6 Foster 5 Bartley 6 Davis 7 Edu 4 Ness 6 McCulloch 6 Hutton 6 Weiss 7 Wylde 6 Diouf 5 Naismith 8 Lafferty 7 Jelavic 9 Miller 9 Healy 3 Beattie 1 Yes I can live with your choices. 0 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.