Super_Ally 0 Posted October 22, 2009 Share Posted October 22, 2009 (edited) We’ve all done it. In fact we see it on football forums across the World Wide Web at least once every season, often once the dirty business of the transfer window is concluded (or not in Rangers case this season). On every Rangers forum, a bear will start a thread comparing the relative merits of our starting XI and squad with our rivals. In the two-horse race that is the SPL, this really means only our enemy from the East End. It occurs to a lesser degree every time we discuss the next upcoming fixture. Whilst football is not played out on paper we are all guilty, to a certain extent, of pretending it is. We assess the merits of our squad. We compare our players with those of our rivals and mostly come to the opinion that we are the far superior team. Based on our team’s performances since Smith’s return, that is a difficult position to argue against. That is, until this season. Craig wrote an excellent piece discussing the various merits of the two squads. Unsurprisingly, Craig drew the conclusion that we were blessed with greater quality. Reigning Champions, who although we had not strengthened had not been greatly weakened it terms of quality. Celtic was a team in transition if not turmoil. Second best and losing the key players that had kept them just about hanging on to our coat tails. They have replaced those first picks with arguably inferior quality players. Just under a quarter of the way into the season, Craig's analysis stacks up fairly well. After an impressive Old Firm victory saw us close an early gap on Celtic, we regained top spot in the SPL with another victory in Perth. But it is only really down to a stumbling start to the season from Celtic. A start that has seen them pick up just 2 wins in their opening 8 home games in all competitions. This is no better highlighted than by the fact that Celtic had what was a relatively straightforward home game against Motherwell this weekend to maintain their position at the top. As we’ve seen, though, football is played on a large rectangle of grass and not on paper or on a webpage. Motherwell would abhor the thought that they were merely lambs to the slaughter and so it proved as they gained a creditable point away from home. Much like comparing Celtic’s starting XI to Motherwell’s, on paper Rangers are more than a match for anyone in the SPL, including our less illustrious rivals. Yet we have yet to demonstrate this dominance in any game of note this season. Sandwiching a creditable draw in Stuttgart, we went on a run of goalless draws against the dross of the SPL and threw in a narrow victory over Queen of the South. At Fir Park, Rugby Park and at home to Aberdeen, as well as in travelling to Palmerston we continually failed to show our superiority in class and footballing ability. Weekend after weekend, game after game, 45 minutes in Germany aside, we failed to demonstrate the quality of a football team that could spend millions on Steve Davis (Ã?£3mil), Pedro Mendes (Ã?£3mil) and Madjid Bougherra (Ã?£2.5mil). Whilst we are blessed with household names and international and former English Premiership stars, the likes of Aberdeen or Kilmarnock field players who would be anonymous in their own neighbourhood and earn a fraction of our players wage packet. Previous Rangers teams have gained from winning championships and trophies. It has developed a sense of invulnerability. A belief they can win against the odds and had many an opponent defeated before they entered the field of play. Look at the NIAR teams for a real strength of character and a winning mentality fostered on past successes. So why are our current squad so brittle? Why do they lack that strength of belief in their own ability? They are champions and should play with the confidence and swagger that brings. Of gravest concern is the midfield. Steve Davis is an international footballer and former premiership star of immense experience, even for his relatively modest years. He has demonstrated his superiority to the best of the rest in this country before as he ran the show in an Old Firm match in which he scored the vital winner. So why is he part of a midfield dominated by the part-timers of Queen of the South or the less celebrated SPL sides? Pedro Mendes, like Davis is an international star; recently helping Portugal get their World Cup campaign back on track in guiding them to the play offs. He has also played in a Champions League winning side. Yet the occasional deft flick and long range strike is barely acceptable from the most talented and experienced midfielder at Murray Park and in Scotland. What too of Kevin Thomson? Admittedly he is still regaining match sharpness. Perhaps that can account for his rash sending off in his first game back. In all truth he was probably rushed back due to suspensions and a dwindling squad. Can it still excuse an inability to execute the basics several matches later? Like Davis he has performed a starring role, complete with obligatory winning goal in an Old Firm game. In fact, we have won every derby encounter the former Hibs star has contested. If he is more than a match for the most difficult opposition we can face domestically, where does this ability go when facing the lesser lights of Scottish football? The term "Paper Champion" has a few connotations or meanings. It identifies a Champion who is merely a place holder. Someone who is the title holder in name, but really the sporting fraternity know they are not deserving and are waiting for a competitor of true champion quality to emerge and assume the mantle. Last season, few would argue, Walter Smith’s Rangers confirmed their place as the dominant force in Scottish football. On paper, we are in our own league. The Hibs, Hearts and Celtic cannot compete. Last season, this was certainly true. When the fixture calendar rolled round to Old Firm day or a contest with the capital clubs, more often than not our players demonstrated their greater quality that was evident on paper. But this season I am left asking myself if that gap in ability between ourselves and our challengers is really there? Was it an illusion? Are we merely paper champions? If my analysis of the relative strengths of SPL sides is worth anything and we really are the most talented group of players it is time we started proving it on match days. No more turning up and relying on a few star performers to save the skins of lazy players who believe they have made it and no longer think they have to work for victory against your Falkirks, St Johnstones and Hibernians. Starting this week I want to see a Rangers side filled with the quality of true champions and not the recent paper champions. Edited October 23, 2009 by Super_Ally missed fullstop 0 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Super_Ally 0 Posted October 23, 2009 Author Share Posted October 23, 2009 Moved this in here from the writer's forum. 0 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
bmck 117 Posted October 23, 2009 Share Posted October 23, 2009 another excellent-bitta-prose, sir. 0 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Super_Ally 0 Posted October 23, 2009 Author Share Posted October 23, 2009 :cheers: mate. Maybe need to right something more inflammatory next time though. Ps. Did you get time to write those other comments? 0 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
bmck 117 Posted October 23, 2009 Share Posted October 23, 2009 not yet man; work is horrible just now, and study intense. should hopefully get some time at the weekend. 0 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Super_Ally 0 Posted October 23, 2009 Author Share Posted October 23, 2009 No worries. :cheers: in advance. 0 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.