Match Thread [FT] Celtic 2 - 1 Rangers (Tavernier 88)

[Rousseau 9,373]

10 minutes ago, CammyF said:

But they are now saying it was offside. Why are they pushing offside when it want a penalty?

 

They've tied themselves in knots over the non-award and appears even they don't know why it wasn't given. 

 

Hopefully the club keep the pressure on. 

Have you got a source for all these VAR releases? I'd love to see them. 

 

Most of this mess is coming from fans and 'journalists' pushing controversy, IMO.

[RANGERRAB 3,258]

Much debate about the handball penalty and the incompetence of the officials but I thought the Dessers one was more of a penalty because Johnston doesn’t play the ball & brings down Dessers. Was Collum asleep again?

And the biggest mystery of all, how did Johnston & Bernardo avoid second yellow cards? During the live commentary Kenny Miller made the point johnston had committed 3 or 4 fouls since his booking. Only Walsh can explain that one.

When was a Celtic player last sent off at Celtic park against Rangers ?

[CammyF 6,784]

Just now, RANGERRAB said:

Much debate about the handball penalty and the incompetence of the officials but I thought the Dessers one was more of a penalty because Johnston doesn’t play the ball & brings down Dessers. Was Collum asleep again?

And the biggest mystery of all, how did Johnston & Bernardo avoid second yellow cards? During the live commentary Kenny Miller made the point johnston had committed 3 or 4 fouls since his booking. Only Walsh can explain that one.

When was a Celtic player last sent off at Celtic park against Rangers ?

It's been 13 years since we've had a penalty at Parkhead - kinda goes against the Penalty To Rangers narrative. 

 

I see ex-ref Steve Conroy has confirmed that any offside should not stop a penalty being awarded.

 

as for red cards, I can't comment but also can't remember the last time they had a red card at Parkhead against us.

 

[CammyF 6,784]

[RANGERRAB 3,258]

My understanding was VAR and Bly rules on offside at goals. Yesterday wasn’t a goal so VAR couldn’t call offside 

[Rousseau 9,373]

5 minutes ago, CammyF said:

"[i.e.] a goal [or a penalty]", surely?

[CammyF 6,784]

No, that's why Conroy says offside is irrelevant in this situation. 

[RANGERRAB 3,258]

6 minutes ago, CammyF said:

No, that's why Conroy says offside is irrelevant in this situation. 

As per my above post 😎
offside would have to have been given by the match referee or linesman.

It wasn’t given offside. Play restarted with a goal kick

Edited January 1 by RANGERRAB
Xyz

[Rousseau 9,373]

7 minutes ago, CammyF said:

No, that's why Conroy says offside is irrelevant in this situation. 

@RANGERRAB @CammyF

 

IFAB:

 

'The categories of decision/incident which may be reviewed in the event of a

potential ‘clear and obvious error’ or ‘serious missed incident’ are:

 

[...]

 

b. Penalty kick/no penalty kick

• attacking team offence in the build-up to the penalty incident

(handball, foul, offside etc.)

• ball out of play prior to the incident

• location of offence (inside or outside the penalty area)

• penalty kick incorrectly awarded

• penalty kick offence not penalised'

[RANGERRAB 3,258]

7 minutes ago, Rousseau said:

@RANGERRAB @CammyF

 

IFAB:

 

'The categories of decision/incident which may be reviewed in the event of a

potential ‘clear and obvious error’ or ‘serious missed incident’ are:

 

[...]

 

b. Penalty kick/no penalty kick

• attacking team offence in the build-up to the penalty incident

(handball, foul, offside etc.)

• ball out of play prior to the incident

• location of offence (inside or outside the penalty area)

• penalty kick incorrectly awarded

• penalty kick offence not penalised'

The offside ( if it was offside) was missed.