Should Beale be sacked?

[CammyF 6,976]

9 minutes ago, Rousseau said:

No - it does not make sense to me. 

Shame, as it makes perfect sense. We are becoming a poisoned challis.

Edited September 30, 2023 by CammyF

[Gonzo79 13,841]

Okay.

 

I think you're trying to say we should just give in then, in a round about way.

 

I still think bringing in a new manager will provide us with improved performances and results.

[CammyF 6,976]

Just now, Gonzo79 said:

Okay.

 

I think you're trying to say we should just give in then, in a round about way.

 

I still think bringing in a new manager will provide us with improved performances and results.

It's not what I'm saying but no matter. 

 

A new manager will provide improved performances and results, but short of winning the league will be deemed a failure and the fans will want them sacked - am I wrong in that assumption?

 

[PoohBear 1,099]

Just now, Gonzo79 said:

Okay.

 

I think you're trying to say we should just give in then, in a round about way.

 

I still think bringing in a new manager will provide us with improved performances and results.

Which manager are you going to bring in? We can’t just bring in a manager who will provide us with improved performances and results, that is not enough. When I said the other day that I would prefer McInnes to Beale I was roundly slagged off. To be clear, I don’t want McInnes, but he would get us improved performances and results I have no doubt. 
 

What we really need is the correct appointment, someone who can win us the league, someone experienced who isn’t another gamble. Every single appointment since Smith has been a fucking gamble. The problem is that we have made our club completely undesirable to anyone with any sort of pedigree.

[CammyF 6,976]

1 minute ago, PoohBear said:

Which manager are you going to bring in? We can’t just bring in a manager who will provide us with improved performances and results, that is not enough. When I said the other day that I would prefer McInnes to Beale I was roundly slagged off. To be clear, I don’t want McInnes, but he would get us improved performances and results I have no doubt. 
 

What we really need is the correct appointment, someone who can win us the league, someone experienced who isn’t another gamble. Every single appointment since Smith has been a fucking gamble. The problem is that we have made our club completely undesirable to anyone with any sort of pedigree.

The only manager to win the top flight title since Smith took 3 years to win it. Most Rangers fans wanted him sacked long before we secured 55 and its safe to say Covid and lock down saved hom from being sacked. 

[Gonzo79 13,841]

8 minutes ago, CammyF said:

short of winning the league will be deemed a failure and the fans will want them sacked - am I wrong in that assumption?

This season is all but done, so I think you are wrong.  

[CammyF 6,976]

4 minutes ago, Gonzo79 said:

This season is all but done, so I think you are wrong.  

Really? So if they fail to win the title the following year? Or lose a couple of games in the first 20 or so league games of the following season? 

[Gonzo79 13,841]

Just now, CammyF said:

Really? So if they fail to win the title the following year? Or lose a couple of games in the first 20 or so league games of the following season? 

All depends on circumstances. 

 

GvB's team looked hopeless in the end, as does Beale's team now.  

 

If there's something positive about the way we're playing and the players look up for it, the fans will tolerate bad results more.  Depends what that lot are doing too, of course.  

[CammyF 6,976]

3 minutes ago, Gonzo79 said:

All depends on circumstances. 

 

GvB's team looked hopeless in the end, as does Beale's team now.  

 

If there's something positive about the way we're playing and the players look up for it, the fans will tolerate bad results more.  Depends what that lot are doing too, of course.  

Unfortunately that lot appear to have a board who make them millions, make far more correct decisions, have a business plan that drives their football operation. In fact, and it kills me to say it, they have everything that we don't. 

[Gonzo79 13,841]

It is starting to feel like a Bayern Munich v Borussia Dortmund thing in Scotland, unfortunately. 

 

However, unlike the Dortmund fan base, I don't think we'll continue to turn up in numbers.