bmck

was referring to this bit: Gazza, Laudrup and Cooper, were, in my opinion, infinitely more skillful than RDB.

i dunno. i didnt think milan were too clever - some neat passing, but not much end product. celtic are in with a chance, i think.

man, oh, man cammy - we cant agree on a thing just now. rdb done absolutely nothing compared with gazza or laudrup!

hehe. :admin:

any more of this and you will be banned.

see, cammy, told you you were wrong.

very true.

i'd unfortunately disagree with this - i know a lot of racist people, and can only assume they are somewhat representative. this, of course, doesn't justify it in any way.

it is a false dilemma cammy. you are asking me whether i would prefer to be 19 points ahead or have a 40 goal a season striker. but its clearly not one or the other - there are much more factors in play, like the quality of surrounding players, for instance. even though i'd rather be in celtic's position, it doesn't mean its a true dilemma.

in what way do BJK posters help redress this problem?

false dilemma m8 - 1) rangers being 19 points clear etc is nothing to do with boyd's ability - our poor position cant be attributed to his scoring goals. 2) celtic also have 20+ a season goalscorers - but kenny miller, the man in question, isnt one of them.

cammy, for my money you are making your analysis of him far, far too simple. these things are not in doubt: 1. he's scored at every level he's played 2. he scores a lot of goals 3. he's currently in a very uncreative team also 4. he hasn't scored against celtic 5. he hasn't scored in europe however, he's young and he's not had that many opportunities, and always against a much stronger celtic side than we've had. its just too early to judge him, though i can appreciate we all have gut-insticts about players.

just seems petty to me.

no, i obviously meant he's the best goal-scorer we have - and that he is a better goal scorer than kenny miller. thats all i've said throughout, and is demonstrable.

Cammy - no-one's saying he's the best player on the planet, we're just saying he's the best player we have.

LM is incompetent. mixing football and politics is clearly stupid, but there's a far greater injustice is unequal treatment of supporters.

i think its a simple matter of superiority - standing with your hand up singing rule britannia is simply more dramatic. far too much is made out of this.

i hope all those who are there will, but i have my doubts.

do you honestly think that any games/goals ratio will show in kenny miller's favour? if kenny miller has scored more goals at a higher level it is only because he's significantly older and has played more. someone who cant score more than ten goals in a season, irrespective of where they score them, isnt a better striker than one who nets 30 (two players playing in the same league, that is).

thank goodness you are not the manager. i cant believe you said that.

realised that man. i'll have a wee look into it.

no, i agree fully. we've been crying out for someone for a very long time who just regularly kicks the ball into the goals - now that we've got someone i think its important we put him to full use. there's no doubt he could/can improve, but our whole squad could, and i dont think it is right to judge him too harshly till he's surrounded by good players.

i think you can choose the old polls from a drop down list when you view the current one.

he just seems to score. i think with better service we'd get a lot more out of him. right now we have no creativity in the final third and he's still scoring - imagine him with a busy creative second forward, and a few attacking midfielders? i reckon he could still cement his place.

clearly!