Should we bid £5million for McGinn..?

[buster. 4,808]

If we sign John McGinn, a Unicorn will post on Gersnet.

 

Wait a minute............!!!! 

[ranger_syntax 3,778]

Continually mystified by how often this gets mentioned on forums.

 

I will be polite and describe it as improbable.

 

Not the strangest suggestion I've seen though. Recently saw someone on twitter suggesting McGeouch. 

[colinstein 294]

Mcgeoch played for us before I think

[Frankie 8,153]

There is no chance of us signing McGinn.

 

Hibs won't sell him to us and the player won't come either.  He may end up at Celtic but more likely he'll move to England.

[alskoosher 14]

In the first instance where would we get £5 million and we need to spend on a manager first and foremost.

[buster. 4,808]

1 hour ago, Frankie said:

There is no chance of us signing McGinn.

 

Hibs won't sell him to us and the player won't come either.  He may end up at Celtic but more likely he'll move to England.

I'll be very surprised if he doesn't end up at Parkhead.

 

It's a 'no-brainer' of a signing for them and I wouldn't be surprised if McGinn had already been tipped a wink and was now running his contract down with an agreement of sorts in place that saw him receive a hefty signing-on fee.

 

Hibs might try and cash in this summer but they aren't in a position to ask for what would represent 'value'.

Edited April 24, 2018 by buster.

[StuGers 477]

Lol.

[Rousseau 9,390]

McGinn's a good player -- although he's not a goalscorer (20 goals in 6 seasons). 

 

If we could get him, we should go for it. 

 

However, it's very unlikely, as Frankie outlined. 

[buster. 4,808]

7 minutes ago, Rousseau said:

McGinn's a good player -- although he's not a goalscorer (20 goals in 6 seasons). 

 

If we could get him, we should go for it. 

 

However, it's very unlikely, as Frankie outlined. 

I think what you have at the moment is an M8 player corridor between Hibs and Celtic that has an unwritten 'rule'.

 

- No player shall go to Rangers

 

The example of Scott Allan is a good one. Once within, it was very difficult he get out. Hibs wouldn't sell to Rangers and Celtic saw the opportunity to prevent Rangers get a decent Number 10 and do some business. That business has resulted in loan deals that saw Allan directly involved for other clubs taking points from Rangers but unable to be fielded against them. It may result in him being used as a makeweight for a McGinn deal to celtic and that in turn would have him back at a club that won't sell him to Rangers.

[Bluedell 5,346]

1 hour ago, alskoosher said:

In the first instance where would we get £5 million and we need to spend on a manager first and foremost.

This. We aren't in the position to spend £5m on a player.