Court of Session rules in favour of HMRC + Rangers Issue Statement

[BlueMazza 0]

I would imagine its re heard with shit like this presented as evidence.

 

I'd probably need to go back and look at the last time we won, but I imagine it would say similar, for our argument.

[Little General 80]

But they haven't won the case, they haven't proven anything. As far as I can tell, they've won the right to appeal the original ruling. What I want to know is, does the ruling get thrown out if the appeal wins, or is a whole new trial required?

 

The way I see it is that the appeal has been allowed, therefore HMRC have indeed won.

[jhunter 0]

The way I see it is that the appeal has been allowed, therefore HMRC have indeed won.

 

Does the defendent MIH have the right to appeal this decision?

[BlueMazza 0]

Carson's Cat ‏@CarsonsCat 3m3 minutes ago

To put the confusion on here to bed, the COS has allowed the HMRC appeal. Now up to SDM to seek leave to appeal to Supreme Court.

[chilledbear 16]

The way I see it is that the appeal has been allowed, therefore HMRC have indeed won.

 

They have won the right to appeal, nothing more.

 

Can Murray appeal against this judgement ?

[Davie P 4]

I would imagine that this spells the end of King's suggestion of the possibility of merging Oldco and Newco?

[Little General 80]

They have won the right to appeal, nothing more.

 

Can Murray appeal against this judgement ?

 

not the way I see it. Appeal has been allowed in favour of HMRC. they don't need to appeal again.

 

MIH will now have to appeal (if he wishes to do so) to Supreme court which is the next step in the chain.

[Frankie 8,150]

I think Little General is correct.

 

Appeal allowed means the Court has decided in favour of the Appellant (party bringing the appeal). However, I do believe MIH will appeal so I'd imagine the case will continue.

[forlanssister 3,050]

not the way I see it. Appeal has been allowed in favour of HMRC. they don't need to appeal again.

 

MIH will now have to appeal (if he wishes to do so) to Supreme court which is the next step in the chain.

 

The fly in the ointment being that MIH is being liquidated and I think it's fair to say Lloyds the main creditor won't fund any appeal which effectively means it would be up to OldCo (for all intents and purposes BDO) to fund any further action.

[forlanssister 3,050]

I think Little General is correct.

 

Appeal allowed means the Court has decided in favour of the Appellant (party bringing the appeal). However, I do believe MIH will appeal so I'd imagine the case will continue.

 

I hope you are indeed correct and that I am wrong in that respect.