Charlie Telfer Decision Reached by Tribunal

[der Berliner 3,249]

He seems to be doing a decent enough job without spending money, who knows perhaps he'd rather Hearts invested in their youth system than spunk it on overpaid over the hill journeymen like some other managers.

 

Hearts appear to have a long term plan in place whereas we can't even see past f*&king Christmas.

 

The point is that they did not have any money to spend and lost half of their team if not more. Did he sign any players for "meaningful fees"?

[ian1964 10,418]

Maybe the reason Thompson was seething is he needed the extra cash for his take over?

 

 

Scottish club Dundee United could step in and buy struggling A-League club Newcastle Jets.

 

 

 

SCOTTISH giants Dundee United are believed to be involved in negotiations to buy struggling A-League club Newcastle Jets from troubled millionaire Nathan Tinkler.

 

Dundee officials, including chairman Stephen Thompson, were in Newcastle late last week for meetings with key Jets officials and attended the club’s game against Wellington last Saturday night at Hunter Stadium.

 

It’s understood they inspected Northern NSW Football Federation’s new facility at Speers Point during their visit to the city.

 

Thompson is believed to have also held talks with FFA offficials while in Australia and has met with other A-League clubs including Adelaide, Perth, Sydney and Western Sydney during the past three weeks while in the country.

 

He was guest of Adelaide United late last month, attending an FFA Cup game against Central Coast, with the chairman saying at the time he was “constructing relationships” that could lead to promising young Australian players spending time in Dundee.

 

It is common knowledge the Jets franchise is for sale with Tinkler telling The Daily Telegraph in August he “can’t wait to get them out the door”.

 

That followed his decision to relinquish ownership of the Newcastle Knights NRL club.

 

Jets officials Troy Palmer, Robbie Middleby and Michael Bridges travelled to England more than two months ago to sound out possible interested parties in the sale of the Jets.

 

http://m.heraldsun.com.au/sport/football/scottish-club-dundee-united-could-step-in-and-buy-struggling-a-league-club-newcastle-jets/story-fnk6pqhd-1227151802207?nk=07e56b382e0f8520978bea67560dece1

[Ser Barristan Selmy 222]

The point is that they did not have any money to spend and lost half of their team if not more. Did he sign any players for "meaningful fees"?

How many 'meaningful fees' have been spent in Scottish football outwith Celtic since we we signed Templeton?

Edited December 10, 2014 by Ser Barristan Selmy

[forlanssister 3,050]

The point is that they did not have any money to spend and lost half of their team if not more. Did he sign any players for "meaningful fees"?

 

No, he had no choice but to coach the best of what he had, how novel a concept eh?

[TheWee BlueDevil 0]

Bitterly disappointment that we edited the original statement.

 

I've emailed a few fan board members about it

 

Genuine question STB. Are you willing to pass on the email addresses of said fan board members so that we too can ask questions?

 

You seem to be in the loop STB, can we use you as a conduit to get some real answers?

[barca72 440]

Genuine question STB. Are you willing to pass on the email addresses of said fan board members so that we too can ask questions?

 

You seem to be in the loop STB, can we use you as a conduit to get some real answers?

 

 

http://www.rangers.co.uk/fans/fans-board

 

Contact the Rangers Fans Board

 

The Rangers Fans Board was set up to help improve communications between fans and the Club and the 12 members selected are there to represent you, the supporters.

 

If you have a question for one of the members or something you would like raised, please contact the relevant member via email - see below for details. You can contact any one or more of the 12 elected candidates on any issues - they do not have to be issues for that particular category only.

 

Please note, Elected Representatives will not be able to reply to every correspondence they receive and more urgent day-to-day issues or questions should be directed to the Club.

 

Female Fans: Alison Clark-Dick

Email: alisonclarkdick@rangersfansboard.co.uk

 

Families: Christine Murdoch

Email: christinemurdoch@rangersfansboard.co.uk

 

Overseas Fans: Gary Gillan

Email: garygillan@rangersfansboard.co.uk

 

Fans in Glasgow/Govan Community: William Gillan

Email: williamgillan@rangersfansboard.co.uk

 

Disabled Fans: William Paterson

Email: williampaterson@rangersfansboard.co.uk

 

Ethnic Minorities: Zia Islam

Email: ziaislam@rangersfansboard.co.uk

 

Under 18s: William Findlay

Email: williamfindlay@rangersfansboard.co.uk

 

Ibrox match ticket purchasers: Robert Callaghan

Email: robertcallaghan@rangersfansboard.co.uk

 

Corporate Fans: Tom Clements

Email: tomclements@rangersfansboard.co.uk

 

Rangers Official Members: Tom Johnstone

Email: tomjohnstone@rangersfansboard.co.uk

 

Season Ticket Holders: Alan Fraser

Email: alanfraser@rangersfansboard.co.uk

[Super Cooper 0]

Genuine question STB. Are you willing to pass on the email addresses of said fan board members so that we too can ask questions?

 

You seem to be in the loop STB, can we use you as a conduit to get some real answers?

 

They are on the official website i am sure, certainly not secret.

[the gunslinger 3,366]

Genuine question STB. Are you willing to pass on the email addresses of said fan board members so that we too can ask questions?

 

You seem to be in the loop STB, can we use you as a conduit to get some real answers?

 

Stb was just taking a minute out from sex pesting Alison to talk football.

[Scott7 5,179]

"SCOTTISH giants Dundee United ......" (#114)

 

Whit?

[ian1964 10,418]

Rangers were sold short by SPFL tribunal over Charlie Telfer transfer fiasco

 

RANGERS signed Charlie Telfer when he was just a boy and nurtured him for 10 years after that.

 

So I think £204,000 is a perfectly reasonable amount of money for Dundee United to pay for his services.

 

Yes, I accept that Telfer only featured in one first team game for the Ibrox club - as a substitute against Stenhousemuir last season.

 

But the 19-year-old is an excellent prospect and has done well at United where he has forced his way into Jackie McNamara's team.

 

The young midfielder was named SPFL Young Player of the Month for November this week.

 

The fee agreed upon is not an awful lot of money to pay for an individual with huge potential like that.

 

Stephen Thompson has, surprise, surprise, reacted with fury to the decision of the SPFL tribunal.

 

But the United chairman has always got something to moan about - especially when it has anything to do with Rangers.

 

There is no doubt in my mind he was pandering to United fans with his comments. And not for the first time either.

 

Thompson certainly hasn't had anything quite as bad to say about the club on the other side of Glasgow over the years.

 

He has a real bee in bonnet about Rangers for some reason.

 

I think that he, and many others in the Scottish game, would be far better off minding their own business and concentrating on their own club.

 

Rangers are the most hated club in Scotland. Nobody likes them and everyone has enjoyed giving them a kicking while they have been down.

 

When the future of Rangers was being deliberated two years ago Thompson and the United fans were among the most vocal about what should happen.

 

But Rangers supporters have good memories. They can recall which clubs were against them and which clubs wanted them to do them down.

 

It will be interesting to see how they respond when the Ibrox club finally gets back into the SPFL Premiership.

 

These clubs get huge increases in income, from corporate hospitality and ticket sales in general, whenever Rangers come to play.

 

Their coffers are swelled by tens of thousands of pounds whenever Ally McCoist's side roll into town.

 

I am sure a few travelling supporters will say: "Do I really want to give my money to this club after what they did and said? Stuff them!"

 

Anyway, the fee for Telfer has nothing whatsoever to do with Rangers. It was decided by a tribunal.

 

The Tannadice club had initially offered £60,000 for the player. Then they upped that to £100,000.

 

Rangers wanted £300,000. So the fee that was agreed was a reasonable compromise.

 

To say, as Thompson has, that it sets a worrying precedent and could restrict movement of young players between clubs is wide of the mark too.

 

If Telfer develops on Tayside they will be able to sell him for a far greater transfer fee in the future.

 

Charlie is a certainly good young player.

 

He was unhappy that he wasn't featuring in the first team at Rangers and chose to move on.

 

But the manager was seeing him in training on a daily basis. If he was doing well enough then surely he would have been given a run.

 

Anyway, young players leave clubs and go on and prove themselves elsewhere all the time in football.

 

It even happened to Ally McCoist. He was told he wasn't good enough and was shown the door by St. Mirren as a kid when Alex Ferguson was manager.

 

Anyway, Rangers offered Telfer a new contract in the summer and he decided to turn it down.

 

To say, as many have, that Rangers don't give young players a chance is just nonsense. Look at the players they have blooded in the last couple of years.

 

Sure, only Lewis Macleod and Fraser Aird are currently playing on a regular basis in the first team.

 

But there are others who are out on loan, not least Callum Gallagher and Barrie McKay, who are more than good enough to feature in the future.

 

In fact, I wouldn't be surprised if they were brought back to Ibrox for the second half of the season.

 

These players have shown what they are capable of when they have been given the nod by McCoist in the past and can do so once again.

 

http://www.eveningtimes.co.uk/rangers/rangerscomment/rangers-were-sold-short-by-spfl-tribunal-over-charlie-telfer-transfer-191679n.114393072